Skip to main content

CarMax vs Carvana: Strategic Comparison

Direct Answer

CarMax is bigger by revenue and vehicles sold, while Carvana is far more profitable and much more valuable in the stock market. CarMax reported $25.88 billion in net sales for fiscal 2026 (ended February 28, 2026) and sold 780,684 retail used vehicles, compared with Carvana's $20.32 billion in revenue and 596,641 retail units for calendar 2025. Carvana's net income of $1.895 billion was more than seven times CarMax's $247.3 million, and Carvana's market capitalization of about $70.2 billion on October 1, 2026 was nearly nine times CarMax's $7.9 billion.

Carvana is worth nearly nine times as much as CarMax in the stock market, even though CarMax sells more cars and books more revenue: Carvana's market capitalization was about $70.2 billion on October 1, 2026, against CarMax's $7.9 billion, despite CarMax posting $25.88 billion in net sales for fiscal 2026 (ended February 28, 2026) versus Carvana's $20.32 billion for calendar 2025. CarMax, founded in 1993 by Richard L. Sharp and Austin Ligon as a Circuit City venture, is the older and larger retailer by units, selling 780,684 vehicles at retail in fiscal 2026 against Carvana's 596,641 in 2025. Carvana, started in 2012 by Ernest Garcia III, Ryan Keeton and Ben Huston, has been run by Garcia as CEO since founding, while CarMax installed its third leader in under a year when Keith Barr became president and CEO on March 16, 2026. On profit, Carvana is far ahead: it earned $1.895 billion in net income in 2025, more than seven times CarMax's $247.3 million in fiscal 2026, even though CarMax's revenue was 27% higher.

Editorial research by Swet Parvadiya. Figures keep each company's fiscal year; amounts reported in another currency are shown in US dollars at an approximate rate and marked with ~. Sources are listed below.

Share

Key Differences at a Glance

FieldCarMax, Inc.Carvana Co.
Latest annual revenue$25.9B (FY2026)$20.3B (FY2025)
Founded19932012
Employees27,79623,100
Market Cap$9.1B$48.3B
HeadquartersUnited StatesUnited States
Revenue / Employee$931k / employee$880k / employee
Valuation Multiple0.4x P/S2.4x P/S

Strategic Positioning

Business model and competitive context from the cited profiles

CarMax, Inc. Strategic Vector

FY2026 Revenue Baseline

CarMax is deliberately giving up per-car profit to regain share: Q2 fiscal 2027 retail gross profit per unit fell $111 to $2,105, yet net earnings rose because volume, EPP margins, CAF income, and SG&A leverage more than offset it. The test is whether that trade holds as CAF takes on more non-prime credit.

Productivity: $931k / employee

Carvana Co. Strategic Vector

FY2025 Revenue Baseline

Carvana's profit growth since 2023 comes mainly from operating leverage: fixed costs in reconditioning, logistics and technology are being spread across far more vehicles, while gain-on-sale loan income adds high-margin profit to each sale.

Productivity: $880k / employee
Comparative Divergence: CarMax and Carvana are the two largest national used-car retailers, and CarMax's own public filings name Carvana as a direct online rival alongside AutoNation and Lithia. The rivalry intensified through 2025 and 2026: Carvana's retail units grew more than 40% for six straight quarters through Q1 2026 and the company joined the S&P 500 in December 2025, just as CarMax changed CEOs twice in under a year and wrote off its remaining goodwill. CarMax answered with its 'Shift into GEAR' plan under Keith Barr, cutting prices and reconditioning costs to win back volume, and posted a 13.8% retail-unit gain in Q2 fiscal 2027 that narrowed Carvana's growth lead for the first time since 2023. Both companies are now pushing deeper into financing to defend margins: Carvana through its related-party lender Bridgecrest, and CarMax by expanding CarMax Auto Finance into higher-risk Tier 2 and Tier 3 borrowers, where CAF financed 22% of Tier 2 volume in Q2 fiscal 2027 versus 10% a year earlier.

CarMax vs Carvana Market Share

CarMax, Inc. market share
CarMax is the largest used-car retailer in the U.S. by units, selling 780,684 retail vehicles in fiscal 2026, but the market is so fragmented that its share of total U.S. used-car sales is in the low single digits.
Carvana Co. market share
Carvana is the second-largest U.S. used-car retailer by retail units after CarMax, but with about 597,000 retail sales in 2025 it holds only a low single-digit share of the roughly 35-40 million annual U.S. used-vehicle transactions.

Quick Stats Comparison

MetricCarMax, Inc.Carvana Co.
Revenue$25.9B (FY2026)$20.3B (FY2025)
Founded19932012
HeadquartersRichmond, VirginiaTempe, Arizona
Market Cap$9.1B$48.3B
Employees27,79623,100
Revenue / Employee$931k / employee$880k / employee
Valuation Multiple0.4x P/S2.4x P/S

CarMax Revenue vs Carvana Revenue — Year by Year

YearCarMax, Inc.Carvana Co.Higher reported revenue
2026$25.9BN/AOnly one figure available
2025$26.4B$20.3BCarMax, Inc. (approx. USD)
2024$26.5B$13.7BCarMax, Inc. (approx. USD)
2023$29.7B$10.8BCarMax, Inc. (approx. USD)
2022$31.9B$13.6BCarMax, Inc. (approx. USD)

Business Model Breakdown

Overview: CarMax, Inc. vs Carvana Co.

This in-depth comparison examines CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. across revenue, market value, business model, competitive positioning, and long-term growth strategy. Whether you are researching CarMax, Inc. on its own, evaluating Carvana Co., or weighing the two companies side by side, the breakdown below highlights where each company leads and where the gap between CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. is widest.

On the headline numbers, annual revenue is $25.9B (FY2026) for CarMax, Inc. and $20.3B (FY2025) for Carvana Co., while their respective market capitalizations stand at $9.1B and $48.3B. Both CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. are headquartered in United States. Their local markets and applicable rules may still differ.

CarMax, Inc.: CarMax fundamentally transformed the sleazy, high-pressure world of buying a used car in America. Before CarMax, buying a used car meant negotiating with a highly commissioned salesman in a plaid suit at an independent lot. CarMax disrupted this entirely by introducing a 'no-haggle, no-pressure' corporate retail model. With large, superstore lots across the country and a large online inventory, they applied the clean, standardized corporate efficiency of a Best Buy or Target to the chaotic used car industry, becoming the largest retailer of used cars in the US. The company is headquartered in Richmond, Virginia.

Carvana Co.: Carvana turned used-car buying into an e-commerce transaction: customers browse inventory with 360-degree photos, get financing terms online, trade in their old car and schedule delivery or pickup, backed by a 7-day return policy. The company went public on the NYSE in 2017, nearly collapsed in 2022, and joined the S&P 500 in December 2025 after a turnaround that delivered record profits. The company is headquartered in Tempe, Arizona.

Business Models: How CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. Make Money

CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. pursue distinct approaches to generating revenue, and understanding how each company operates is the foundation of any fair comparison between CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co..

CarMax, Inc. business model: CarMax buys used vehicles from consumers (whether or not they buy a car), from dealers, and at auctions, reconditions the ones that meet its retail standard, and sells them at fixed prices online, in stores, or through a mix of both. Vehicles that do not meet the retail standard are sold to licensed dealers in CarMax's online wholesale auctions. On top of the vehicle margin, CarMax earns income from CarMax Auto Finance loans, fees from third-party lenders, and commissions on extended protection plans (EPP). In fiscal 2026, used vehicle sales were 80.0% of revenue, wholesale 17.4%, and other sales and revenues 2.6%; CAF contributed $562.7 million of income, reported separately from revenue.

Carvana Co. business model: Carvana earns money in three ways. First, it sells used vehicles online at a retail margin; it buys inventory from consumers (its "sell your car" instant offers), auctions and partners, reconditions cars in its own Inspection and Reconditioning Centers (IRCs), and delivers them with an in-house trucking network. Second, it earns "other" gross profit by originating auto loans for customers and selling those loans to investors and securitization trusts, plus commissions on vehicle service contracts and GAP waiver coverage. Third, it sells cars that do not meet its retail standard through wholesale channels, including the ADESA U.S. physical auctions it bought in 2022. Loan servicing is handled by Bridgecrest, an affiliate of the Garcia family-controlled DriveTime, under related-party agreements disclosed in Carvana filings.

Competitive Advantage: CarMax, Inc. vs Carvana Co.

The durability of a company's moat often decides long-term winners. Here is how the competitive advantages of CarMax, Inc. stack up against those of Carvana Co..

CarMax, Inc. competitive advantage: CarMax's advantage is scale combined with vertical integration. It appraises and buys well over a million vehicles a year from consumers and dealers, which feeds both its retail lots and its own wholesale auctions, and it owns the reconditioning, logistics, pricing, and financing steps that pure marketplaces outsource. A national store network lets customers test drive, trade in, or pick up locally, while CarMax Auto Finance and third-party lenders let it approve most credit tiers at the point of sale. Edmunds adds an owned automotive research audience. No competitor combines retail, wholesale auctions, captive finance, and a brick-and-mortar footprint at the same scale.

Carvana Co. competitive advantage: Carvana's edge is vertical integration at national scale: one online storefront with a large centralized inventory, its own reconditioning centers, an in-house car-hauling fleet, a captive lending operation and, since 2022, ADESA's 56 U.S. auction sites to expand reconditioning capacity closer to customers. Each additional car sold spreads those fixed costs, which is why SG&A per unit has kept falling as volume rises.

Growth Strategy: Where CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. Are Headed

Future prospects matter as much as current results. The growth strategies below explain how CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. each plan to expand from here.

CarMax, Inc. growth strategy: Keith Barr's 'Shift into GEAR' plan has four pillars: Great Offering (price competitively across demand cycles and grow saleable inventory), Easy Experience (connect digital tools with in-store service to lift conversion), Add Value (grow CAF and EPP profitability), and Run Lean (cut reconditioning, logistics, and SG&A costs). CAF's full-spectrum lending push is a central lever: in Q2 fiscal 2027 CAF financed 22% of Tier 2 volume versus 10% a year earlier. CarMax also continues to build stand-alone reconditioning and auction centers to support future volume.

Carvana Co. growth strategy: Since 2023 Carvana has prioritized profitable growth over expansion at any cost. Its playbook: convert ADESA auction sites into reconditioning hubs, shorten delivery times through regional inventory and same-day delivery, widen selection by adding inventory, and lower per-unit costs so savings can be passed to customers as lower prices. It also sells cars through partnerships and is growing wholesale and dealer-facing services on the ADESA platform.

Financial Picture: CarMax, Inc. vs Carvana Co.

A closer look at the financial trajectory of CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. rounds out the comparison.

CarMax, Inc.: CarMax's revenue is large but its margins are thin: in fiscal 2026 it booked $25.88 billion of net sales and operating revenues, $2.81 billion of gross profit (10.8%), $562.7 million of CAF income, and $2.45 billion of SG&A, leaving $247.3 million of net earnings ($1.68 per diluted share, or $2.91 adjusted). That compares with $26.35 billion of revenue and $500.6 million of net earnings in fiscal 2025, and a peak of $29.68 billion of revenue in fiscal 2023. The fourth quarter of fiscal 2026 included a $141.3 million non-cash goodwill impairment, wiping out the goodwill on the balance sheet. CarMax repurchased $631.8 million of stock in fiscal 2026, paused buybacks in Q4, and said in September 2026 it would resume them in Q3 fiscal 2027 after Q2 net earnings of $165.3 million on $7.9 billion of revenue. CarMax is the largest used-car retailer in the United States, sustaining a strong market valuation typically over $10 billion.

Carvana Co.: Carvana's revenue grew from $3.9 billion in 2019 to $12.8 billion in 2021, then the company lost $2.9 billion in 2022 as used-car prices and interest rates moved against it after the ADESA purchase. A 2023 debt exchange cut debt and extended maturities, and cost cuts pushed the company back to profit: net income was $150 million in 2023, $404 million in 2024 and a record $1.895 billion in 2025 (including a large non-cash tax benefit in Q4 2025), with 2025 adjusted EBITDA of $2.237 billion. In 2026, Q1 revenue was $6.432 billion with $405 million net income, and Q2 revenue was $7.376 billion with $513 million net income and record adjusted EBITDA of $769 million. Carvana is known for its highly volatile stock, but it maintains a massive multi-billion dollar valuation driven by its e-commerce approach to auto retail.

Company-Specific SWOT Notes

CarMax, Inc.

Strength

CarMax sold 780,684 retail and 538,203 wholesale vehicles in fiscal 2026 through about 256 stores.

Strength

CAF generated $562.7 million of income in fiscal 2026 and financed 42.4% of retail units.

Weakness

Net earnings were just 1.0% of fiscal 2026 revenue ($247.3 million on $25.88 billion) and fell 50.6% year over year.

Weakness

The 2026 sales rebound relies on lower prices: retail gross profit per unit fell to $2,115 in Q4 fiscal 2026 and $2,105 in Q2 fiscal 2027, and wholesale profit per unit fell to $858.

Opportunity

Management targets $200 million of exit-rate SG&A savings by the end of fiscal 2027; Q2 fiscal 2027 SG&A per total unit already improved 8.8%.

Threat

Carvana's rapid growth since 2023 and digital investments by franchise dealer groups intensify competition for online-first buyers and for consumer-sourced inventory.

Carvana Co.

Strength

Carvana in-house loan origination allows it to retain the high-margin interest spread and backend F&I income on the auto loans it originates, a profit center that directly contributed to the company record 9.3% net income margin in FY2025.

Strength

Carvana runs one online storefront with centralized inventory, its own reconditioning centers, an in-house car-hauling fleet, a captive lending operation and, since 2022, ADESA's 56 U.S. auction sites.

Weakness

The company centralized reconditioning centers and vending machines require capital expenditure and fixed overhead, a structural weakness that can rapidly erode margins during periods of low retail demand, as seen during the 2022 downturn when the company was

Opportunity

With Bridgecrest now profitable, Carvana has the opportunity to expand its financing products to prime consumers, a market segment representing over 60% of all auto loans, an opportunity that could add billions in high-margin loan origination fees and interest

Threat

Legacy dealership groups like AutoNation and Lithia Motors are investing heavily in their own e-commerce platforms and localized delivery networks, using their existing physical service departments and established relationships with local consumers to offer a

Factual Scorecard

CategoryResultWhy
Same-period Revenue ScaleNot comparableCarMax: $25.9B (FY2026). Carvana: $20.3B (FY2025). Different or missing fiscal periods prevent a like-for-like ranking.
Founded EarlierCarMax, Inc.CarMax, Inc. was founded in 1993; Carvana Co. was founded in 2012.
Verdict

Comparison Takeaway: CarMax vs Carvana

CarMax and Carvana are both recovering from rough patches, but on different trajectories. CarMax's revenue fell 1.8% in fiscal 2026 to $25.88 billion and net earnings halved to $247.3 million after a $141.3 million goodwill impairment, a 0.96% net margin, before new CEO Keith Barr's price cuts helped second-quarter fiscal 2027 revenue jump 19.5% to $7.9 billion. Carvana's 2025 revenue grew 49% to $20.32 billion with a 9.3% net margin, and growth kept accelerating into 2026, with Q2 2026 revenue up 52% to $7.376 billion and record adjusted EBITDA of $769 million. CarMax still has the physical-scale advantage, with about 256 stores, its own wholesale auction network, and CarMax Auto Finance generating $562.7 million of income in fiscal 2026, while Carvana runs a smaller footprint of reconditioning centers and vending-machine towers but converts far more of each sales dollar into profit. The market's roughly nine-times valuation premium for Carvana over CarMax, despite CarMax's larger revenue, shows investors are pricing Carvana's growth rate and margin trajectory above CarMax's current revenue scale.

Methodology and sourcing reviewed by Swet Parvadiya. No date is shown unless this comparison has its own editorial review date.

Frequently Asked Questions: CarMax vs Carvana

Is CarMax or Carvana bigger by revenue?

CarMax is bigger by revenue. It reported $25.88 billion in net sales for fiscal 2026 (ended February 28, 2026), about 27% more than Carvana's $20.32 billion in revenue for calendar 2025. CarMax also sold more vehicles at retail, 780,684 against Carvana's 596,641.

Which is more profitable, CarMax or Carvana?

Carvana is far more profitable. It earned $1.895 billion in net income in 2025, a 9.3% net margin, versus CarMax's $247.3 million in fiscal 2026, a 0.96% net margin after a $141.3 million goodwill impairment. Carvana's profit was more than seven times CarMax's despite 27% less revenue.

Who are the CEOs of CarMax and Carvana?

Keith Barr has been CarMax's president and CEO since March 16, 2026, succeeding interim CEO David McCreight after Bill Nash's nine-year tenure ended in late 2025. Ernest Garcia III has led Carvana as CEO since he co-founded the company in 2012 with Ryan Keeton and Ben Huston.

Why is Carvana worth more than CarMax on the stock market?

Investors are pricing Carvana's growth and margins above CarMax's larger revenue base. Carvana's market capitalization was about $70.2 billion on October 1, 2026, versus CarMax's $7.9 billion, even though CarMax's $25.88 billion of fiscal 2026 revenue topped Carvana's $20.32 billion. Carvana's revenue grew 49% in 2025 while CarMax's fell 1.8%, which drives much of the gap.

Which is better to buy a used car from, CarMax or Carvana?

It depends on what the buyer wants. CarMax offers about 256 physical stores plus online ordering and sold 780,684 retail units in fiscal 2026, suiting buyers who want to test drive in person. Carvana is fully online with home delivery and vending-machine pickup towers, delivering 596,641 vehicles in 2025, suiting buyers who prefer a contactless purchase.

Which company was founded first, CarMax, Inc. or Carvana Co.?

CarMax, Inc. was founded in 1993; Carvana Co. was founded in 2012.

What revenue did CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. report?

CarMax, Inc. had $25.9B (FY2026), while Carvana Co. had $20.3B (FY2025). The fiscal years differ, so these are not a like-for-like same-period comparison.

How do CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. make money?

CarMax, Inc.: CarMax buys used vehicles from consumers (whether or not they buy a car), from dealers, and at auctions, reconditions the ones that meet its retail standard, and sells them at fixed prices online, in stores, or through a mix of both. Carvana Co.: Carvana earns money in three ways.

Which is better, CarMax, Inc. or Carvana Co.?

There is no evidence-based single winner. Compare CarMax, Inc. and Carvana Co. on the same fiscal period and the metric relevant to the question, such as revenue, profitability, growth, product fit, or market value.

Sources & References

Quick Answer

CarMax is bigger by revenue and vehicles sold, while Carvana is far more profitable and much more valuable in the stock market. CarMax reported $25.88 billion in net sales for fiscal 2026 (ended February 28, 2026) and sold 780,684 retail used vehicles, compared with Carvana's $20.32 billion in revenue and 596,641 retail units for calendar 2025. Carvana's net income of $1.895 billion was more than seven times CarMax's $247.3 million, and Carvana's market capitalization of about $70.2 billion on October 1, 2026 was nearly nine times CarMax's $7.9 billion.

Verdict

CarMax and Carvana are both recovering from rough patches, but on different trajectories. CarMax's revenue fell 1.8% in fiscal 2026 to $25.88 billion and net earnings halved to $247.3 million after a $141.3 million goodwill impairment, a 0.96% net margin, before new CEO Keith Barr's price cuts helped second-quarter fiscal 2027 revenue jump 19.5% to $7.9 billion. Carvana's 2025 revenue grew 49% to $20.32 billion with a 9.3% net margin, and growth kept accelerating into 2026, with Q2 2026 revenue up 52% to $7.376 billion and record adjusted EBITDA of $769 million. CarMax still has the physical-scale advantage, with about 256 stores, its own wholesale auction network, and CarMax Auto Finance generating $562.7 million of income in fiscal 2026, while Carvana runs a smaller footprint of reconditioning centers and vending-machine towers but converts far more of each sales dollar into profit. The market's roughly nine-times valuation premium for Carvana over CarMax, despite CarMax's larger revenue, shows investors are pricing Carvana's growth rate and margin trajectory above CarMax's current revenue scale.

Cite This Page

Automatically generated citations for researchers.

APA Format

CorpDigest. (2026). CarMax, Inc. vs Carvana Co. Comparison. from https://corpdigest.com/compare/carmax-vs-carvana

MLA Format

CorpDigest. "CarMax, Inc. vs Carvana Co. Comparison." CorpDigest, 2026, https://corpdigest.com/compare/carmax-vs-carvana.

Chicago Format

CorpDigest. "CarMax, Inc. vs Carvana Co. Comparison." CorpDigest. 2026. https://corpdigest.com/compare/carmax-vs-carvana.

Content is for informational purposes only. Not financial advice. Data sourced from SEC filings, annual reports, and public records. See our full disclaimer and methodology.